Author Beta
Denne siden er maskinoversatt og kan inneholde feil. Rapporter en oversettelsesfeil · Vis på engelsk

Moral dilemmas and difficult decisions

Write moral dilemmas in fiction with two defensible options, each protecting something and costing something, and a decision that reveals character.

IntermediateAbout 40 minutes, plus writingGratisUpdated

By the end: An option matrix for a real dilemma, the decision scene, and a note on what changed in the character.
Helps to have: A character who cares about at least two things.
A real dilemmaTwo defensible options, each protecting one value at the cost of another.Value ASomethingthat mattersValue BSomething elsethat mattersOptionsEach protects one,costs the otherChoiceRevealsthe character

A dilemma isn’t an obstacle

An obstacle asks how to reach a goal. A dilemma asks which of two things you care about you’ll protect. Moral dilemmas in fiction reveal character because the choice shows what matters most to this person, without the narrator announcing a verdict.

Build one from two obligations that can’t both be met: a journalist torn between the truth and a vulnerable source; a mechanic deciding whether to reveal a family secret that could save other people’s livelihoods.

Two costs. Sarah finds a document that may undermine Victor’s claim. It also suggests her father knew about an unresolved debt tied to another family’s land. Making it public could save the garage and damage her father’s memory; hiding it could protect his name and leave others at risk. Nothing about the document is settled canon here; you decide what it means.

Avoid false dilemmas

If one option is harmless and effective, readers will wonder why the character doesn’t take it. Either explain why they can’t, or make both options costly. And dilemmas needn’t demand shocking sacrifice: small, realistic choices often reveal more.

Change, even if the choice is wrong

After the decision, something inside the character shifts, even if they chose badly. Write down what. Keep the rejected option, too: it may return as a consequence, or as the road not taken that haunts them later.

Small dilemmas count

Not every dilemma involves life or death. Whether to tell a friend their work isn’t ready, whether to keep a promise that no longer makes sense, whether to accept a job that would mean leaving: everyday choices reveal values just as clearly. A string of small, well-chosen dilemmas can build a character more convincingly than one dramatic sacrifice.

Common pitfalls

  • Irrational obstacles invented to force a choice.
  • Ethics turned into a score.
  • An easy right-or-wrong test dressed as a dilemma.

Check your understanding

What makes a dilemma real?

Your turn

Build the option matrix, then write the decision.

What you type here stays in this browser until you save it to your Desk. It’s kept on this device if you leave and come back.

What this saves to your book
  • The decision, with its options and consequences, on the Timeline
  • The scene in Ideas

Rejected options are kept with the decision. Encrypted in your browser first.

You’ll need a free account to save. Your answers wait here while you sign up.

Take it with you: Free for everyone. Made in your browser from what you typed above.

AI assistance optional, off

Off unless you switch it on. Ask about the lesson, get a hint, or have your exercise reviewed against this lesson’s checklist. It never writes the exercise for you. Questions and hints send only your question (we add the lesson). A review sends only the answers you copy into the box. Nothing from your Writing Desk or your books is ever sent, and every request shows you exactly what will leave, and to which AI service, before you send it. Don’t include anything private or confidential. Feedback is advice and may be wrong; it never changes your progress, and every lesson can be finished without AI.

Sign in to use AI assistance.

Check your work

These are prompts, not rules. Done when: An event or Ideas saved in one of your Writing Desk projects.

If you get stuck

If one option keeps winning, raise the cost of the obvious choice, or the value of the other.

Decisions on the Timeline let you trace their consequences chapter by chapter.

Related: Writing grief, fear, anger, joy and hope · Escalating tension without repeating the same obstacle · All of Conflict & Human Emotion

Sources and further reading

  1. Writing Fiction: The Practical Guide, Gotham Writers Workshop, ed. Alexander Steele (Bloomsbury). Checked Nov 19, 2026. A beginner’s craft book covering character, plot, point of view, dialogue and revision.
  2. Start writing fiction (free course), The Open University, OpenLearn. Checked Nov 19, 2026. A free university introduction to fiction writing: character and conflict.

This lesson and its examples are original to Author Academy. Sources are cited for ideas and further reading; nothing is copied from them, and no institution endorses this course. Version 1.