Competing desires
Competing desires in fiction make choices matter: give a character two aims worth wanting, then let one constraint force an imperfect, visible choice.
Helps to have: AB101 Creative Writing Foundations, or a finished draft of your own.
The idea
A useful way to deepen motivation is to give a person more than one legitimate desire. A conservator may want to display an object and protect it from light. A pilot may want to depart on schedule and keep a promise to someone who is late. These are not automatically signs of hypocrisy. The conflict emerges when circumstances prevent satisfying both in the usual way.
Move from a list of values to a decision. What does the person actually attempt? Which alternative becomes harder because of that attempt? Let the scene produce evidence of priority rather than attaching a label such as selfish or loyal. A person may misunderstand their own reasons; the writer can preserve that uncertainty.
Un esempio svolto
At the community observatory, Leena wants the public to hear the first recording from its new receiver. She also promised apprentice Tomas that he would present it. Tomas is still checking a possible error when the visitors arrive. Leena places his name card beside the microphone, then leaves her own notes open on the lectern.
The preparation keeps both desires alive. The next event must test whether she will preserve the apprentice’s role when delay has a cost.
Why competing desires in fiction matter
Competing desires in fiction turn a character from a list of qualities into a person making decisions. When both aims are defensible, the reader can’t simply cheer for the right answer; they watch to see which one the character protects, and at what price. You don’t need extreme stakes. A promise to an apprentice against the success of a public event is enough, as long as the constraint is concrete and the choice changes what can happen next. The choice is your evidence of priority, so you never have to label the character selfish or loyal.
The same pressure in another genre
In a Western, a ranch hand wants to ride for the doctor and also wants to keep the herd from scattering in the storm; there is one horse fit to travel. In a romance, a woman wants the job offer in another city and wants the relationship that only just started. The pattern is identical: two goods, one action that serves one at the other’s expense. Notice that neither example needs a villain. When you can’t find the conflict in a scene, look for a second thing the character values that the first goal quietly threatens, then give the scene a constraint that forces them to act before they’re ready.
A longer demonstration: The demonstration
First sketch
Leena wanted the presentation to go well. She was worried because Tomas had not finished checking his calculations. She told him that it was time. He said he needed more time because accuracy was important. They argued. Leena realized he was right and decided to delay the presentation. The audience would be disappointed, but she knew she had done the correct thing.
Revised
The visitors had filled every chair except Tomas’s. Leena turned his name card toward the aisle, where he would see it when he came in.
He stopped beside the lectern with the correction sheet in both hands.
“One minute,” she whispered.
“I need you to read this first.”
“The recording is four minutes long. We can discuss the calibration afterward.”
He put the sheet over her introduction. At the top, where the committee required the responsible researcher’s name, he had written hers.
She looked at him. “You changed the attribution?”
“They returned the last one unsigned. I thought they might read yours.”
A visitor in the front row raised a phone. Leena moved the microphone down, then up again. It was already at the correct height.
“Is it wrong?” she asked.
“I don’t know yet.”
That answer had irritated her all week. Now she could see the erased figures underneath it, the places where he had tried to be certain.
She took her introduction from beneath his sheet.
“Keep your name card here,” she said. “We’ll tell them what we have, and what we haven’t checked.”
He did not sit down. “Both of us?”
Leena turned the second chair toward the lectern.
What the revision changes
The sketch states motivation and verdict. The revision stages a practical conflict, adds an attribution decision and gives uncertainty a concrete form. The chair and name card recur with changed significance. The final gesture suggests a changed working arrangement without proving that every future disagreement is solved.
Tradeoff: the revision takes more space and makes attribution a central concern. If the larger story is about an entirely different subject, this emphasis might be excessive. “Show more” is not a sufficient reason to preserve it.
Try it
Identify a sentence that remains close to Leena, a fact she learns, and an inference the reader might make but cannot prove. Then write a different ending in which she postpones the event without resolving the attribution issue. Explain which relationship question remains open.
Practise it
Give an invented person two aims that are both defensible. Write 250-400 words in which a practical constraint makes them choose an imperfect action.
In your own project: Create a two-aim map for your capstone protagonist. Identify the scene where the aims become incompatible.
Common pitfalls
- One aim that exists only to be defeated.
- Labelling the dilemma (“she felt torn”) instead of staging a choice.
- A conflict that dissolves because both aims turn out to be compatible after all.
Think it through
Leena immediately makes the presentation herself. What would you need to show before calling this action a meaningful conflict rather than a simple preference?
Compare with a suggested answer
Evidence that preserving Tomas’s role matters to her, that delay has a specific cost, and that her decision affects a later option. A label such as conflicted is not enough.
Other answers can be just as good if you can point to evidence in the text.
Your turn
Work here or on paper. What you type stays in this browser until you save it to your Desk.
AI assistance optional, off
Off unless you switch it on. Ask about the lesson, get a hint, or have your exercise reviewed against this lesson’s checklist. It never writes the exercise for you. Questions and hints send only your question (we add the lesson). A review sends only the answers you copy into the box. Nothing from your Writing Desk or your books is ever sent, and every request shows you exactly what will leave, and to which AI service, before you send it. Don’t include anything private or confidential. Feedback is advice and may be wrong; it never changes your progress, and every lesson can be finished without AI.
Sign in to use AI assistance.
Try this first
If one aim exists only to be defeated, make its value concrete. Do not assume a sympathetic motive excuses the resulting harm.
Still stuck?
Check your work
These are prompts, not rules. Done when: Your work saved to your Desk, or marked done if you did it elsewhere. Self-reviewed, not graded. Counts toward your certificate of completion.
If you get stuck
If one aim exists only to be defeated, make its value concrete. Do not assume a sympathetic motive excuses the resulting harm.
Everything you save here is searchable in your Writing Desk and ready to move into a chapter.
Related: Agency and obstacles · All of Fiction Craft
Sources and further reading
- Start writing fiction (free course), The Open University, OpenLearn. Checked Nov 19, 2026. A free university introduction to fiction writing: character, setting and genre.
- Creative writing and critical reading: Reading as a writer, The Open University, OpenLearn. Checked Nov 19, 2026. Reading closely for point of view, rhythm, imagery, voice, structure and theme.
This lesson and its examples are original to Author Academy. Sources are cited for ideas and further reading; nothing is copied from them, and no institution endorses this course. Version 1.