Author Beta
Questa pagina è tradotta automaticamente e può contenere errori. Segnala un errore di traduzione · Mostra in inglese

How to evaluate your first draft: diagnose before you polish

How to revise a first draft without wasted work: read it whole, compare what you meant with what is on the page, and pick five problems to fix first.

BeginnerAbout 40 minutes, plus writingGratisUpdated

By the end: A revision diagnosis in your Story Bible and up to five prioritised revision problems in Ideas, each with evidence from your pages.
Helps to have: A complete first draft, or a long section of one. Take a Desk snapshot of each chapter before you start.
Four levels of a draftCheck the broadest level first: a change to the story can make sentence polishing on later levels wasted work.StoryPromise, causeand effect, climaxCharactersGoals, choices,changeScenesConflict, change,specific detailLanguageClarity andcorrectnessFix what could invalidate later work first.

Finishing isn’t the same as knowing what to change

When you sit down to revise a first draft, the commas on page one are tempting: they’re visible and easy to fix. But if the central conflict needs redesigning, many of those polished sentences will be cut later. Begin by reading the whole manuscript, and separate what is working from what is unfinished. This first pass changes nothing. It isn’t a punishment, and you don’t have to fix anything yet.

Three questions

Read with three questions in mind. What did I intend readers to experience? What does the manuscript actually make them experience? Where is the gap between the two widest? Then look at four levels: the story (its promise, cause and effect, and climax), the characters (goals, choices, how they change), the scenes (conflict, change, specific detail) and the language (clarity and correctness). Work on the level that could make work on the others pointless.

Example. Suppose a draft spends six chapters on Sarah’s daily life at the garage and introduces the developer’s claim on the property in chapter seven. The intention was a suspenseful fight to save the garage. A fair diagnosis: the central conflict arrives too late. But don’t cut six chapters on reflex. First check whether those scenes set up something essential. One remedy is to open with the locked garage and weave the earlier material in later; another is to give the early chapters sharper goals. A diagnosis is an open question, not an automatic rewrite.

Rate your confidence, not your talent

For each level, note how sure you are of your diagnosis: well supported, uncertain, or needs an outside reader. That stops a passing doubt from turning into a rewrite, and tells you where beta readers would help most. Then choose no more than five high-impact problems, each tied to a chapter or scene you can point to.

Keep what you like

Write down three things that already work. Revision is easier when you know what you’re protecting, and the best parts of a first draft are often the ones a nervous reviser cuts first.

Common pitfalls

  • Line-editing chapter one before you know whether the story works.
  • Treating your own preference on a reread as a fact about the book.
  • A list of thirty problems instead of the five that matter most.
  • Cutting scenes before checking what they set up.

Check your understanding

Your draft’s central conflict arrives in chapter seven. What should you do first?

Your turn

Read your draft through once without changing anything, then fill this in.

Fills the boxes with the worked example, so you can see how it saves. Change anything.

What you type here stays in this browser until you save it to your Desk. It’s kept on this device if you leave and come back.

What this saves to your book
  • Your revision diagnosis in the Story Bible
  • Each revision problem as its own card in Ideas

Your chapters are not touched. Take a snapshot of each chapter in the Desk before you start changing them. Encrypted in your browser first.

You’ll need a free account to save. Your answers wait here while you sign up.

Take it with you: Free for everyone. Made in your browser from what you typed above.

AI assistance optional, off

Off unless you switch it on. Ask about the lesson, get a hint, or have your exercise reviewed against this lesson’s checklist. It never writes the exercise for you. Questions and hints send only your question (we add the lesson). A review sends only the answers you copy into the box. Nothing from your Writing Desk or your books is ever sent, and every request shows you exactly what will leave, and to which AI service, before you send it. Don’t include anything private or confidential. Feedback is advice and may be wrong; it never changes your progress, and every lesson can be finished without AI.

Sign in to use AI assistance.

Check your work

These are prompts, not rules. Done when: A Story Bible entry or Ideas saved in one of your Writing Desk projects.

Before changing a chapter, take a snapshot of it in the Desk (Snapshots, in the chapter’s inspector). You can always go back.

Related: Developmental editing: repair the story before the sentences · Revising characters, relationships and arcs: earn the change on the page · All of Revision & Editorial Lab

Sources and further reading

  1. Types of Editing: A Breakdown for Writers, Savannah Cordova, Reedsy. Checked Nov 19, 2026. The stages of editing in the order a book usually goes through them, with examples.
  2. Editorial Service Definitions, Editorial Freelancers Association. Checked Nov 19, 2026. How professional editors describe developmental editing, line editing, copyediting and proofreading.

This lesson and its examples are original to Author Academy. Sources are cited for ideas and further reading; nothing is copied from them, and no institution endorses this course. Version 1.