Author Beta
Esta página está traducida automáticamente y puede contener errores. Informar de un error de traducción · Ver en inglés

Audit rules and consequences

Audit science fiction continuity: check timing, who knows what and when, and every rule your story established, then repair what arrives too early.

IntermediateAbout 45 minutes, plus writingGratisUpdated

By the end: Check continuity, knowledge and timing against the assumptions actually established.
Audit rules and consequencesCheck continuity, knowledge and timing against the assumptions actually established.RulesWhat the storyestablishedTimingWhen thingscan happenKnowledgeWho knowswhat, whenRepairFix orredesign

The idea

Create a rule audit: rule, where established, where used, consequence and possible exception. Exceptions need preparation or a deliberate reinterpretation, not a convenient final-page waiver. Track who knows each relevant fact and when.

For delayed communication, distinguish send time, arrival time, processing duration, response preparation and scheduled access. A reply cannot incorporate information that has not reached its sender under your model. A pre-recorded message may arrive later without being a response to intervening events. An audit checks these dependencies, not scientific validity of every assumption.

Un ejemplo resuelto

Under the stipulated twelve-minute one-way delay, a question sent at 09:01 arrives at 09:13. An immediate reply cannot arrive back before 09:25. A clip received at 09:10 must have another origin, not that question.

The reply that arrives too early

If messages take twenty minutes, a reply can’t arrive in five. Science fiction continuity errors often hide in timing and knowledge: a character reacts to news that hasn’t reached them yet. Audit your rules, your timeline and who knows what at each point.

When you find an error, try two repairs: correct the timeline, or redesign the moment (a message recorded in advance, sent before the question).

Practise on the teaching story

The original teaching story below, “The Reply Window”, comes with its message audit. Check its timing yourself before reading the audit, then apply the same method to your own draft.

The teaching story: The Reply Window

An original story of about 1,263 words written for this course. Check its message timing before you read on: does every reply arrive when the rules allow?

Read “The Reply Window”

At nine, the wrong tune arrived from Ilan’s sister.

That was how it felt. The file appeared beside the clock in the station’s listening room, Mina’s face filling the little screen above a keyboard. She played six notes, lifted her hands, and looked pleased with herself.

“Same one,” she said. “Unless you’ve forgotten.”

Ilan had not forgotten. He had practiced the other six notes for a week.

He looked at the file again. The message clock showed that she had sent it at eight forty-eight. Twelve minutes to reach him; another twelve for anything he sent back. The app put the delay beneath every recording, as if repetition might make the number ordinary.

His outgoing personal-audio slot closed at nine twenty. The next one was at ten. Mina’s small farewell performance began at nine twenty-six, in a room on Earth where people could hear one another hesitate without waiting for a file.

He pressed record.

“Which version?” he asked. “You’re playing the old opening. I learned the one from the blue notebook.”

He sent the question at nine oh one and kept his hand beside the microphone, prepared to ask it more clearly when she replied.

Jae came in carrying two stools. She set one beneath the screen and the other beside Ilan’s instrument.

“When can she answer that?” she asked.

“Nine twenty-five.”

“And when does your slot end?”

“I know.”

Jae sat down without saying the number. He disliked her a little for making him supply it himself.

The room was borrowed from the language club. Its shelves held card games, folded screens and objects people had brought so that explaining them would give everyone something to talk about. Ilan had contributed an old wooden kitchen spoon. Mina had once used it to beat time on the table while he practiced. He took it from the shelf now and laid it across his knees.

They had called the piece Back Step because, as children, they could never agree where the first beat belonged. One began alone; the other entered on the gap. Then they exchanged parts. The mistake was the joke, and the joke was knowing exactly when the other person would make it.

For the farewell, Mina was leaving the room where they had first played it. Not leaving Earth, not going somewhere he could not send a recording. The building was being given another use. She would take her keyboard away at the end of the afternoon, and the people who had sat through their childhood performances were coming to hear it once more.

Ilan had told her he could be there in sound.

He opened the blue notebook. In the corner of the page, Mina had drawn an arrow through the first measure. PLAY THIS BIT TWICE, she had written. Below it, in his own handwriting: NO.

He had remembered the argument as a settled matter. Apparently he had remembered winning it.

“Play both,” Jae suggested.

“Then she won’t know where to come in.”

“She can listen first.”

“That isn’t the piece.”

Jae picked up the spoon, turned it over, and gave it back. “Show me.”

He played his first line. She tapped a steady count against the stool. It was perfectly sensible and entirely wrong. He stopped.

“She always came in early,” he said.

“Then leave room for early.”

A second file arrived at nine ten. Ilan reached for the microphone before opening it.

“Not an answer,” Jae said.

“I can see the time.”

He could. Sent at eight fifty-eight. Before his question had reached Earth, before he had even recorded it. Mina’s hair was tied back now. Behind her, someone was moving a chair.

“If the first bit sounds different,” she said, “I found the old notebook. Yours has probably improved it. I haven’t.”

She laughed, then leaned closer to the camera.

“Don’t spend your whole morning waiting for my count.”

He replayed that sentence. It had the shape of a reply. The timestamp refused to let it become one.

At nine twelve he started his recording.

He held the spoon where she would see it and struck four beats against his knee. On the fifth he played the opening from his notebook, then stopped before the answering phrase. The silence felt much too long. He nearly filled it.

Jae was still. He could hear someone outside the room trying a word in a language they had not yet learned, repeating it more softly each time.

He began again, but not from the beginning. He played the line Mina had sent, as well as he could remember it, and left another gap. This time the empty space had a shape. It was not Mina’s part yet. It was somewhere her part could go.

At the end he said, “Take whichever opening you want. I left the count in.”

The recording lasted two minutes. He sent it at nine fourteen.

The app marked its expected arrival as nine twenty-six.

Jae moved her stool away from the microphone. Ilan opened the file, listening to the silence he had made. Without Mina it sounded less like a duet than an instrument being tested by someone repeatedly distracted.

“I could have played her part as well,” he said.

“Then what would she do?”

He did not answer. Outside, the language learner had found someone to say the word back. Neither repetition sounded quite like the other.

At nine twenty his personal sending slot ended. The incoming list stayed open. The distinction was printed on the booking page; he had checked it six times that morning. Still, when the send button turned gray, he felt as though someone had shut a door against both of them.

He put the blue notebook away, then took it out again.

Mina’s answer to his question arrived at nine twenty-five.

“Either,” she said. “I don’t care which one. Don’t tell anyone I said that.”

Her message was short because, at nine thirteen on her side, she had still been getting the room ready. She had not heard his performance yet. She could not be forgiving it, praising it or wishing he had done something else.

He let himself be irritated by the answer that would have been useful eleven minutes earlier.

Jae went to find tea. Ilan put the spoon back on the shelf, with its worn bowl turned outward. It had no business looking like something a person might need.

At nine forty, a new audio file arrived. Mina had begun making it at nine twenty-six and sent it at nine twenty-eight.

He called Jae before he played it.

His four spoon beats came first. Then his own opening, the one from the blue notebook. Mina entered early, just where he had left enough space to make early possible. She used the old answering phrase. It should not have fitted. He could hear the place where she made it fit.

Behind her, someone laughed. Not at the mistake. At recognizing it.

In the second gap she left him a little longer than he needed. He raised his hands to the instrument before remembering that this version had already happened. His earlier self came in without him.

Jae sat on the edge of the stool. When the last note ended, neither of them reached for the replay.

Ilan opened a new recording, one that would wait for the ten o’clock slot.

“I heard where you came in,” he said.

He played Mina’s old phrase back to her, badly on the first attempt and better on the second. He kept both. Then he reached for the spoon.

Practise it

Find and repair a reply that arrives too early. Offer both a timeline correction and a redesign using a clearly pre-recorded message.

For your own project: Completed rule, knowledge and timeline audits with scope limitations.

Common pitfalls

  • Replies faster than the rule allows.
  • Characters knowing things before they could.
  • Fixing one timing error and missing its echoes.

Think it through

Why should transmission windows and propagation delay be separate ledger fields?

Compare with a suggested answer

One governs when a transmission is allowed/available in the fictional system; the other governs travel time after sending. Mixing them can create contradictory access.

Other answers can be just as good if you can point to evidence in the text.

Your turn

Work here or on paper. What you type stays in this browser until you save it to your Desk.

What you type here stays in this browser until you save it to your Desk. It’s kept on this device if you leave and come back.

What this saves to your book
  • Your practice, project work and next step, together in Ideas
  • Your audit in the Story Bible

Saved into your own Desk, encrypted in your browser first. Nothing here is graded; it’s yours to build on.

You’ll need a free account to save. Your answers wait here while you sign up.

Take it with you: Free for everyone. Made in your browser from what you typed above.

AI assistance optional, off

Off unless you switch it on. Ask about the lesson, get a hint, or have your exercise reviewed against this lesson’s checklist. It never writes the exercise for you. Questions and hints send only your question (we add the lesson). A review sends only the answers you copy into the box. Nothing from your Writing Desk or your books is ever sent, and every request shows you exactly what will leave, and to which AI service, before you send it. Don’t include anything private or confidential. Feedback is advice and may be wrong; it never changes your progress, and every lesson can be finished without AI.

Sign in to use AI assistance.

Check your work

These are prompts, not rules. Done when: Your work saved to your Desk, or marked done if you did it elsewhere. Self-reviewed, not graded. Counts toward your certificate of completion.

If you get stuck

If timing errors keep appearing, put every message and event on the Timeline with its time, and read it in order.

Everything you save here is searchable in your Writing Desk and ready to move into a chapter.

Related: Complete the narrative unit · Revise from evidence · All of Science Fiction Writing

Sources and further reading

  1. The Habitable Zone, NASA Science. Checked Nov 19, 2026. NASA’s plain explanation of where liquid water could exist around a star: a model of real-science research for a premise.
  2. Creative writing and critical reading: Reading as a writer, The Open University, OpenLearn. Checked Nov 19, 2026. Reading closely for point of view, structure and the choices behind a story.

This lesson and its examples are original to Author Academy. Sources are cited for ideas and further reading; nothing is copied from them, and no institution endorses this course. Version 1.